[eDebate] ok ok ok just one more real quick one

James C Thomas jct44 at cornell.edu
Thu Jan 11 02:06:33 EST 2007


<<if no one says anything in a debate, why not vote neg on presumption? >>

cuz the neg-case had an alternative and presumption goes aff when there's
an alt otherwise the neg could always run "CP: Do the aff" and always win
actually there are smarter more detailed explanations for why presumption
switches aff when there's a counterplan/counteradvocacy in the debate but
they're probably written by old people.

more beer now.

for realz, mad love,

james



More information about the eDebate mailing list